“But it's obvious it's a bot” — examining the exemption before you rely on it
Article 50(1) doesn’t require a disclosure where interacting with AI is obvious from the point of view of a natural person who is reasonably well-informed, observant and circumspect, taking into account the circumstances and context of use.
Why the bar is higher than you think
The benchmark is your average customer in context — not a tech-savvy founder. Modern chat interfaces are deliberately human-like: typing indicators, first names, natural language. The better your bot, the weaker your “obvious” argument. Voice AI on a phone line is the extreme case: callers default to assuming human.
When the exemption is genuinely solid
The Commission’s guidelines (section 3.2.1) read the exception narrowly: it “should be interpreted restrictively”, it is limited to cases “where there is almost no doubt left about the nature of the interaction”, and where the system may be used by the general public or consumers that include vulnerable people “for whom the interaction is less obvious”, “the exception cannot be relied upon”. Their own examples are closed audiences: code assistants used only by professional developers, internal assistants for trained staff, tools for trained health professionals, AI built into home appliances, and characters in a single-player video game. A chatbot for your customers is none of these. An interface that says in plain words, at the start of the chat, that the user is talking to an AI does not need the exemption at all: that sentence is already the disclosure. The word “assistant” on its own is not one: the guidelines call it ambiguous (point 38).
The economics of the argument
Relying on the exemption saves you a one-line notice and buys you a debatable legal position. Adding the notice costs nearly nothing and ends the question. That’s the whole analysis. We built a widget so the notice is also the best-looking element on the page.
Which of these duties apply to you?
Free, 60 seconds, instant result with exact citations. No email required.
Run the free checkSources are cited in place; official text: Regulation (EU) 2024/1689. This guide is a technical explanation, not legal advice.